서론
연구방법
1. 연구 대상 학회지와 논문
2. 분석 내용
1) 논문 편수와 유형
2) 연구 대상자 및 증상
3) 연구 대상자의 성별과 연령대
4) 연구 대상자의 구성과 수
3. 분석 방법
결과 및 고찰
1 논문 편수와 연구 유형
Table 1.
Table 2.
Field of journal paper | Number of published paper of research type(%) | Total(%) | χ2 | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|||||
Literature research | Investigation research | Experimental research | |||
Horticultural therapy | 12(10.6) | 15(13.3) | 86(76.1) | 113(100) | 82.4** |
Occupation therapy | 41(12.9) | 60(18.8) | 218(68.3) | 319(100) | 55.5** |
Art therapy | 52(10.3) | 123(14.9) | 210(74.7) | 385(100) | 77.5** |
Music therapy | 15(16.1) | 25(26.9) | 53(57.0) | 93(100) | 27.0** |
|
|||||
Total(%) | 120(13.2) | 223(24.5) | 567(62.3) | 910(100) | 39.7** |
2. 연구 대상자의 증상
Table 3.
Particpants | Number of published paper of alternative therapy method(%) | Total(%) | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|||||
Horticultural therapy | Occupation therapy | Art therapy | Music therapy | ||
|
|||||
Stroke | 2( 2.3) | 54(24.8) | 15( 7.1) | 3( 5.7) | 74(13.1) |
A mentally retraded person | 28(32.6) | 11( 5.0) | 24(11.4) | 6(11.3) | 69(12.2) |
Depression | 10(11.6) | 2( 0.9) | 22(10.5) | 8(15.1) | 42( 7.4) |
Demenatia | 5( 5.8) | 12( 5.5) | 13( 6.2) | 5( 9.4) | 35( 6.2) |
Hemiparalysis | 0( 0.0) | 21( 9.6) | 8( 3.8) | 1( 1.9) | 30( 5.3) |
Student | 6( 7.0) | 6( 2.8) | 15( 7.1) | 3( 5.7) | 30( 5.3) |
Barrier to development | 8( 9.3) | 11( 5.0) | 9( 4.3) | 0( 0.0) | 28( 4.9) |
Normal | 0( 0.0) | 23(10.6) | 2( 1.0) | 0( 0.0) | 25( 4.4) |
Personal relations maintain | 0( 0.0) | 0( 0.0) | 22(10.5) | 0( 0.0) | 22( 3.9) |
Children with cerebral palsy | 0( 0.0) | 5( 2.3) | 15( 7.1) | 0( 0.0) | 20( 3.5) |
Community health center law | 0( 0.0) | 13( 6.0) | 7( 3.3) | 0( 0.0) | 20( 3.5) |
Attention dificit disorder | 11(12.8) | 7( 3.2) | 0( 0.0) | 1( 1.9) | 19( 3.4) |
Et cetera disabled person | 0( 0.0) | 4( 1.8) | 9( 4.3) | 6(11.3) | 19( 3.4) |
Facilities | 8( 9.3) | 5( 2.3) | 2( 1.0) | 2( 3.8) | 17( 3.0) |
Preschoolage children | 0( 0.0) | 2( 0.9) | 11( 5.2) | 0( 0.0) | 13( 2.3) |
Stress | 0( 0.0) | 0( 0.0) | 12( 5.7) | 0( 0.0) | 12( 2.1) |
Spinal cord unjure patients | 0( 0.0) | 9( 4.1) | 2( 1.0) | 1( 1.9) | 12( 2.1) |
Autism | 0( 0.0) | 7( 3.2) | 2( 1.0) | 3( 5.7) | 12( 2.1) |
The poor strata | 8( 9.3) | 0( 0.0) | 0( 0.0) | 3( 5.7) | 11( 1.9) |
Hearing impairment | 0( 0.0) | 0( 0.0) | 10( 4.8) | 0( 0.0) | 10( 1.8) |
Alcohlics patient | 0( 0.0) | 0( 0.0) | 4( 1.9) | 2( 3.8) | 6( 1.1) |
Nonoral feeding | 0( 0.0) | 4( 1.8) | 0( 0.0) | 0( 0.0) | 4( 0.7) |
Etc | 0( 0.0) | 22(10.1) | 6( 2.9) | 9(17.0) | 37( 6.5) |
|
|||||
Total %) | 86(100) | 218(100) | 210(100) | 53(100) | 567(100) |
|
|||||
χ2 | 292.9** | 153.5** | 60.8** | 136.7** | 50.2** |
3. 연구 대상자의 성별과 연령대
Table 4.
Classification | Number of gender of participants(%) | Total(%) | χ2 | |
---|---|---|---|---|
|
||||
Man | Woman | |||
|
||||
Horticulturalt herapy | 472(47.9) | 514(52.1) | 986(100) | 0.176NS |
Occupation therapy | 4,728(46.2) | 5,505(53.8) | 10,233(100) | 0.578NS |
Arttherapy | 2,043(47.7) | 2,241(52.3) | 4,284(100) | 0.212NS |
Musictherapy | 706(44.9) | 865(55.1) | 1,571(100) | 1.040NS |
Total(%) | 7,949(46.6) | 9,125(53.4) | 17,074(100) | 0.462NS |
Table 5.
Classification | Number of published paper based on age group of research participant(%) | Total(%) | χ2 | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
||||||||||
Below 19 | 20 | 30 | 40 | 50 | 60 | 70 | Above 80 | |||
|
||||||||||
Horticultural therapy | 38(44.2) | 6(7.0) | 7(8.1) | 2(2.3) | 6(7.0) | 10(11.6) | 16(18.6) | 1(1.2) | 86(100) | 108.4** |
Occupationtherapy | 61(28.0) | 58(26.6) | 23(10.6) | 21(9.6) | 24(11.0) | 20(9.2) | 7(3.2) | 4(1.8) | 218(100) | 53.2** |
Arttherapy | 104(49.5) | 34(16.2) | 22(10.5) | 26(12.4) | 13(6.2) | 3(1.4) | 6(2.9) | 2(1.0) | 210(100) | 141.9** |
Musictherapy | 25(47.2) | 5(9.4) | 6(11.3) | 4(7.5) | 5(9.4) | 2(3.8) | 5(9.4) | 1(1.9) | 53(100) | 115.8** |
|
||||||||||
Total(%) | 228(40.2) | 103(18.2) | 58(10.2) | 53(9.3) | 48(8.5) | 35(6.2) | 34(6.0) | 8(1.4) | 567(100) | 82.9** |
4. 연구 대상자의 구성과 수
Table 6.
Classification | Number of gender of participants(%) | Total(%) | χ2 | |
---|---|---|---|---|
|
||||
Man | Woman | |||
|
||||
Horticultural therapy | 2(2.3) | 84(97.7) | 86(100) | 91.0** |
Occupation therapy | 23(10.6) | 195(89.4) | 218(100) | 62.1** |
Art therapy | 95(45.2) | 115(54.8) | 210(100) | 0.923NS |
Music therapy | 7(13.2) | 46(86.8) | 53(100) | 54.2** |
Total(%) | 127(22.4) | 440(77.6) | 567(100) | 30.5** |
Table 7.
Classification | Number of published paper based on age group of research participant(%) | Total(%) | χ2 | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|||||||||||
1-5z | 6-10 | 11-15 | 16-20 | 21-25 | 26-30 | 31-35 | 36-40 | Above 41 | |||
|
|||||||||||
Horticultural therapy | 13(15.1) | 38(44.2) | 17(19.8) | 4(4.7) | 7(8.1) | 4(4.7) | 1(1.2) | 0(0) | 2(2.3) | 86(100) | 141.9** |
Occupation therapy | 7(3.2) | 18(8.3) | 24(11) | 40(18.3) | 14(6.4) | 11(5) | 15(6.9) | 42(19.3) | 47(21.6) | 218(100) | 33.9** |
Art therapy | 115(54.8) | 38(18.1) | 23(11.0) | 8(3.8) | 13(6.2) | 0(0.0) | 0(0.0) | 5(2.4) | 8(3.8) | 210(100) | 217.0** |
Music therapy | 20(37.7) | 11(20.8) | 6(11.3) | 3(5.7) | 2(3.8) | 4(7.5) | 2(3.8) | 1(1.9) | 4(7.5) | 53(100) | 94.3** |
Total(%) | 155(27.3) | 105(18.5) | 70(12.3) | 55(9.7) | 36(6.3) | 19(3.4) | 18(3.2) | 48(8.5) | 61(10.8) | 567(100 | 42.5** |
5. 프로그램의 시간과 회기 수
Table 8.
Classification | Number of published paper based on age group of research participant(%) | Total(%) | χ2 | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|||||||||
0:00~0:59z | 1:00~1:59 | 2:00~2:59 | 3:00~3:59 | 4:00~4:59 | 5:00~5:59 | Above 6:00 | |||
|
|||||||||
Horticultural therapy | 22(25.6) | 53(61.6) | 11(12.8) | 0(0.0) | 0(0.0) | 0(0.0) | 0(0.0) | 86(100) | 222.9** |
Occupation therapy | 63(28.9) | 44(20.2) | 21(9.6) | 31(14.2) | 0(0.0) | 51(23.4) | 8(3.7) | 218(100) | 46.9** |
Art therapy | 66(31.4) | 92(43.8) | 52(24.8) | 0(0.0) | 0(0.0) | 0(0.0) | 0(0.0) | 210(100) | 146.4** |
Music therapy | 16(30.2) | 11(20.8) | 14(26.4) | 7(13.2) | 5(9.4) | 0(0.0) | 0(0.0) | 53(100) | 61.3** |
|
|||||||||
Total(%) | 167(29.5) | 200(35.3) | 98(17.3) | 38(6.7) | 5(0.9) | 51(9.0) | 8(1.4) | 567(100) | 77.9** |
Table 9.
Table 10.
Total program(No.) | Number of published paper(%) | Total(%) | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Horticultural therapy | Occupation therapy | Art therapy | Music therapy | ||
|
|||||
1~10 | 12(14.0) | 51(23.4) | 43(20.5) | 16(30.2) | 122(21.5) |
11~15 | 20(23.3) | 17(7.8) | 55(26.2) | 11(20.8) | 103(18.2) |
16~20 | 23(26.7) | 28(12.8) | 62(29.5) | 9(17.0) | 122(21.5) |
21~25 | 14(16.3) | 0(0.0) | 26(12.4) | 8(15.1) | 48(8.5) |
26~30 | 4(4.7) | 3(1.4) | 8(3.8) | 4(7.5) | 19(3.4) |
31~35 | 2(2.3) | 4(1.8) | 3(1.4) | 2(3.8) | 11(1.9) |
36~40 | 3(3.5) | 0(0.0) | 7(3.3) | 1(1.9) | 11(1.9) |
41~45 | 2(2.3) | 35(16.1) | 4(1.9) | 1(1.9) | 42(7.4) |
46~50 | 3(3.5) | 21(9.6) | 0(0.0) | 0(0.0) | 24(4.2) |
51~55 | 0(0.0) | 22(10.1) | 0(0.0) | 1(1.9) | 23(4.1) |
56~60 | 0(0.0) | 0(0.0) | 0(0.0) | 0(0.0) | 0(0.0) |
61~65 | 1(1.2) | 18(8.3) | 0(0.0) | 0(0.0) | 19(3.4) |
66~70 | 1(1.2) | 6(2.8) | 0(0.0) | 0(0.0) | 7(1.2) |
Above 71 | 1(1.2) | 13(6.0) | 2(1.0) | 0(0.0) | 16(2.8) |
Total(%) | 86(100) | 218(100) | 210(100) | 53(100) | 567(100) |
|
|||||
χ2 | 148.7** | 87.9** | 202.8** | 171.8** | 103.9** |
6. 프로그램에 사용된 측정 및 평가도구
Table 11.
Evaluation tool | Number of published paper(%) | Total(%) | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|||||
Horticultural therapy | Occupation therapy | Art therapy | Music therapy | ||
|
|||||
1~10 | 12(14.0) | 51(23.4) | 43(20.5) | 16(30.2) | 122(21.5) |
11~15 | 20(23.3) | 17(7.8) | 55(26.2) | 11(20.8) | 103(18.2) |
16~20 | 23(26.7) | 28(12.8) | 62(29.5) | 9(17.0) | 122(21.5) |
21~25 | 14(16.3) | 0(0.0) | 26(12.4) | 8(15.1) | 48(8.5) |
26~30 | 4(4.7) | 3(1.4) | 8(3.8) | 4(7.5) | 19(3.4) |
31~35 | 2(2.3) | 4(1.8) | 3(1.4) | 2(3.8) | 11(1.9) |
36~40 | 3(3.5) | 0(0.0) | 7(3.3) | 1(1.9) | 11(1.9) |
41~45 | 2(2.3) | 35(16.1) | 4(1.9) | 1(1.9) | 42(7.4) |
46~50 | 3(3.5) | 21(9.6) | 0(0.0) | 0(0.0) | 24(4.2) |
51~55 | 0(0.0) | 22(10.1) | 0(0.0) | 1(1.9) | 23(4.1) |
56~60 | 0(0.0) | 0(0.0) | 0(0.0) | 0(0.0) | 0(0.0) |
61~65 | 1(1.2) | 18(8.3) | 0(0.0) | 0(0.0) | 19(3.4) |
66~70 | 1(1.2) | 6(2.8) | 0(0.0) | 0(0.0) | 7(1.2) |
Above 71 | 1(1.2) | 13(6.0) | 2(1.0) | 0(0.0) | 16(2.8) |
Total(%) | 86(100) | 218(100) | 210(100) | 53(100) | 567(100) |
χ2 | 148.7** | 87.9** | 202.8** | 171.8** | 103.9** |