Steel Slag as a Sustainable Amendment: Impacts on Rice Yield, Nutrients and Environmental Safety
Article information
Abstract
Background and objective
In South Korea, significant volumes of steel slag are generated annually, often resulting in disposal as solid waste. Concerns persist regarding alkaline leachate from dumping sites migrating into ecosystems and affecting adjacent rice crops. This study evaluated the feasibility of repurposing steel slag as a sustainable soil amendment to improve rice yield and soil health while ensuring environmental safety.
Methods
Steel slag was applied at different rates (0, 2, 4, and 8 tons per hectare) to paddy soils during pot experiment, to monitor changes in pH, nutrient availability and crop performance. Pot water pH was analyzed throughout the cropping season. Rice plants were characterized for their grain and straw yield. Plants and soil were also analyzed for heavy metals and plant available nutrients.
Results
The results indicate that steel slag significantly increases soil pH from 6.6 to 7.5, neutralizing soil acidity, creating a more favorable environment for rice cultivation. Furthermore, slag application enhanced the availability of essential nutrients including calcium, magnesium, and iron. Notably, plant available SiO2 increased significantly in correlation with application rates. While vegetative growth parameters such as plant height and tiller numbers remained stable, reproductive yield showed improvement, with ripened grain weight peaking at 29.95 g at 8 ton ha−1. Crucially, heavy metals (Cr, Cd, Pb, As) remained undetectable in both the soil and rice components (grain and straw) across all treatments, alleviating immediate toxicity concerns.
Conclusion
Steel slag functions as an effective, ecofriendly soil amendment in paddy rice systems. By optimizing soil pH and significantly boosting SiO2 availability, slag application creates a suitable environment for crop development. The significant increase in grain yield, coupled with the absence of heavy metal accumulation, suggests that steel slag can be successfully transitioned from an industrial byproduct into a valuable agricultural resource, supporting productivity and environmental sustainability.
Introduction
Due to rapid development in steel industries, the annual domestic production of steel in South Korea has reached to almost 71 million tons which is predicted to increase in the near future (Kim et al., 2019) . Additionally, a considerable amount of steel slags is produced as byproduct that constitute almost 40% of the total annual steel production in Korea (Min et al., 2019), with a substantial portion either recycled for various industrial and agricultural purposes or disposed as solid waste at the designated dumping sites. Due to the country’s heavy annual rainfall (approximately average of 1274 mm to 1418 mm), leachate produced from steel slag stockpiles has higher probability to migrate into the surrounding environment. Particularly, local farmers have great concern that leachate from these steel slags may adversely affect the adjacent rice paddies, which are highly sensitive to changes in soil and water pH. If mismanaged, leachate from slag stockpiles may impose severe environmental and human health concerns. These potential environmental impacts of steel slag encouraged many scientists and agriculture experts around the globe to rethink over establishing novel strategies for sustainable and environmentally friendly use of steel slags. However, there is lack of knowledge regarding the extent and nature of these potential impacts. Therefore, the current study aims to evaluate the effect of steel slag on rice growth characteristics and to assess its potential influence on the surrounding agricultural environment.
In South Korea, although, the slags obtained from various sources including blast furnace slag (BFS) and convertor furnace slag (CFS) are widely used in construction and infrastructure, such as road pavements and concrete production, helping reducing greenhouse gas emissions. Additionally, steel slag is used in soil stabilization and even in fertilizers, enhancing rice quality and reducing methane emission. In addition, there is a significant urgency to develop methodologies for using steel slag in areas beyond where slag has been used traditionally such as raw materials and construction of roads. Various studies have reported the beneficial use steel slags. For example, steel slags are highly encouraged for sustainable agricultural use (Meharg and Meharg, 2015). However, due to enlarged volume of slag production, a saturation point has come to an end that resulted into massive stocks of disposing these byproducts as solid waste at various dumping sites, which become a potential environmental liability.
The current investigation suggests a solution to two main issues that have been sparked while tackling steel slag leaching into the external environment causing soil acidification and damaging the crop yield. For this purpose, a pot experiment was conducted to investigate the feasibility of using steel slag as soil amendment in agricultural rice paddies. Furthermore, this investigate also involve to check the effect of using steel slag on rice growth parameters.
Rice cultivation requires specific soil conditions to optimize yield and grain quality. Steel slag, rich in essential minerals including calcium, magnesium and iron, presents a potential sustainable alternative for soil conditioning, particularly in acidic environments. When applied to paddy fields, steel slag is considered to enhance soil pH, particularly in acidic soil, and enhance nutrient availability. This can lead to increase plants productivity and potentially higher rice yield. Moreover, steel slag application in rice paddies has also been reported to reduce methane emissions, which is great contribution to climate change mitigation efforts. Thus, steel slag has been proven effective not only in reducing the greenhouse gases but also as potential candidate for enhancing crop productivity. However, concerns regarding the leaching of heavy metals and the impact of slag-derived leachate on water quality (pH) must be addressed before widespread agricultural adoption. This study aims to evaluate how different concentrations of steel slag influence the physical yield of rice and the chemical evolution of the paddy soil and water environment. The present study therefore aimed (1) to evaluate the impact of using steel slag on enhancing rice yield (2) to evaluate the potential adverse impact of steel slag on soil health (3) to evaluate the environmentally sustainable effect of using steel slag in agricultural rice production. Results from study will provide an important theoretical background for using steel slag to enhance rice yield without enhancing heavy metal contaminants and neutralizing soil acidity.
Research Methods
Experimental Preparation
The pot experiment was conducted from June to September in 2024. The soil used in the current study was collected from the rice experimental field (depth of 30 cm) at agricultural research farm at Gyeongsang National University (36°50′ N, 128°26′ E), Jinju-si, Republic of Korea. The selected soil had a clay loam texture and was classified as typic haplaquent. The soil used in this experiment was characterized with a pH value (1:5 with H2O) of 6.6, and total carbon, total nitrogen, and available P of 11.5 g kg−1, 0.13 g kg−1, and 1.65 g kg−1, respectively as mentioned in Table 1.
Experimental Design
The collected soil was air dried, sieved through 2 mm mesh and packed into Wagner pots (14 kg per pot) each with a diameter of 24 cm and 30 cm in height and bulk density of 1.2 g cm−3. The experiment was arranged in a complete randomized block design (CRBD). Pots were continuously maintained under water submergence (5–7 cm above soil surface) throughout the experimental period. This experiment was performed by installing three replicates for each individual treatment. Steel slags and synthetic fertilizers were added to the soil as per Korean standard recommendation (RDA, 2019). Steel slag was added at different concentrations of 0, 2,4 and 8 ton ha−1 into each individual pot a day before the rice transplanting and pots were flooded with water immediately. The properties of the slag used in the study are presented in Table 2. The basal synthetic fertilizer (N-P2O5-K2O) was applied as per the Korean recommendation (90-45-52 kg ha−1); that include urea, superphosphate and potassium chloride which were applied at the rate of 55, 45 and 40 kg ha−1, respectively as per the recommendations before the rice transplanting. Where as the second split of N (22 kg N ha−1) was applied after 14 days of the rice transplanting at rice tillering stage. in the third split, N and K2O were applied at 33 kg N ha−1 and 18 kg K2O after 42 days after rice transplanting at rice panicle initiation stage. Twenty-one (21) days old rice seedlings of Saenuri cultivar and Japonica type were transplanted with two seedlings per pot.
Analysis of Changes in pot water pH
In order to check the effect of steel slag application on changes in pot water pH, pH was thoroughly checked and measured throughout the rice growing period. pH was measured continuously throughout the experiment with two days interval by using a portable pH meter (pH 200, HM Digital, Inc).
Soil Sampling and Analysis
At harvesting stage of rice plants, soil samples were collected for each treatment of the replicated pots. pH was measured by using pH meter (Orion 3 star, Thermo Electron Corporation). Total Carbon and total nitrogen were measured by using Kjeldahl method (Bremner and Mulvaney, 1982). Soil exchangeable cations including K+, Ca2+, and Mg2+ were extracted with 1 N NH4CH3CO2 (pH 7.0 ) and analyzed by atomic absorption spectrophotometer (Shimadzu 660, Kyoto). The plant available SiO2 and Fe concentrations were analyzed by using above-mentioned methods.
Rice harvesting and Plants characterization
Pots were drained almost a month before the final harvesting. Rice plants were harvested at the age of 120 days. After harvesting, we collected all rice straw from each of the sampled plant, dried it to a consistent moisture level and weighed it determine the straw yield. Replicates from each treatment were collected and plant height was measured. Thereafter, the plants were stored at greenhouse and were air dried. Plants characteristics including tiller numbers and panicle numbers were calculated as per the standard procedure. The number of tillers and number of panicles per plant for each sampled plant were counted at the time of maturity Finally, 100 randomly selected grains were taken, weighed them and calculated the average weight per 100 grains.
Statistical Analysis
All experimental data were analyzed using one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) to compare the effects of different application levels of steel slag (0, 2, 4 and 8 ton ha−1) on the crop yield, plant characteristics and soil parameters. When significant differences were detected (p < 0.05), mean comparisons were performed using Fisher’s Least Significant Difference (FSD) test. Correlation analysis was conducted to examine relationships among yield components, different steel slag application levels and soil parameters. All statistical analyses were performed using SPSS version 20 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA), and results are presented as mean ± standard deviation (SD). Graphs were generated using software such as SigmaPlot.
Results and Discussion
Influence of steel slag on rice yield
Our results clearly demonstrate that steel slag application in soil has significantly improved the rice yield components including straw and grain (Table 3, Fig. 1). The overall data shows that both the rice grain and straw has shown positive correlation with that of the steel slag application, however, both responded slightly differently to the increasing levels of the steel slag. Rice grain was consistently and significantly increased with increasing steel slag fertilization level. For example, it has been increased from 5.6-ton ha−1 at control treatment where no steel slag was applied, to its highest peak of 7.4-ton ha−1 at 8-ton ha−1 of the applied steel slag fertilizer.
Similarly, rice straw has also shown increasing trend with increasing steel slag application levels. However, unlike the grain, straw yield has increased sequentially from 0 to 2 ton ha−1 with a slight decrease at 4 ton ha−1 then ultimately reached to it highest level at 8 to ha−1 of the steel slag application (Fig. 1). Straw yield was almost equal to that of grain yield, both nearing 7.5 to 8 ton ha−1 at the highest level (8 ton ha−1) of steel slag application.
Changes in pot water pH
Pot water pH was monitored throughout the rice cropping season. Our results illustrate the temporal changes in water pH (1:5 H2O) over almost 90 days after rice transplanting, comparing the different levels (2, 4 and 8 ton ha−1) of steel slag application with that of control (0 ton ha−1). Almost similar trends in pot water pH have been shown by all the different levels (2, 4 and 8 ton ha−1) of steel slag fertilization as compare to that of control (0 ton ha−1). A similar trend in pot water pH was observed with sudden increase, soon after the steel slag application in all the steel slag applied treatments and thereafter decreased sequentially until day 40. However, the highest peak in pH was observed by 8 ton ha−1 (10.5) followed by 2 (9.5) and 4 ton ha−1 (10.0), respectively of the steel slag application (Fig. 2). following the initial sharp increase, all the treatments have shown a rapid decline in pH at around 42nd day, eventually stabilizing at lower but slightly elevated range of 7.5 to almost 8 as compared to that of control treatment throughout the cropping season.
Changes in the carbon and nitrogen dynamics
Rice plants and soil has shown significantly positive response to the steel slag application (Table 4, Table 5). Our data clearly illustrates that all the plant growth parameters were significantly increased with increasing the application rates of steel slag. Carbon contents were increased significantly with increasing steel slag application rates, while the highest values were recorded at 4 ton ha−1 of the steel slag application, thereafter decreased suddenly at 8 ton ha−1 of the slag application. Similarly, N contents have also shown similar trends and were increased with increasing the steel slag application levels until 4 ton ha−1 of the steel slag application and thereafter reduced again at 8 ton ha−1 of slag application. Similarly, plant available nutrients including Si, Ca, Mg, and Fe were significantly increased with increasing steel slag application levels (Table 6).
In the current era, the application of industrial waste like steel slag as soil amendment in rice paddies has emerged as a thrilling strategy for improving soil quality and reducing GHG emissions (Wang et al., 2016). These results clearly illustrate that steel slag amendment in rice paddy soil has improved significantly the rice yield and straw (Fig. 2). Which strongly support our hypothesis of using steel slag as soil amendment to enhance rice crop productivity under paddy field conditions, in accordance with the research findings of similar studies conducted in the region with rice production (Wang et al., 2015). The positive correlation observed between steel slag application and rice yield (Fig. 2) aligns with that of previous findings that silicate fertilizers enhance reproductive growth in rice crops. The increase in grain yield from 5.6 ton ha−1 to 7.4 ton ha−1 at the highest application rate of steel slag (8 ton ha−1) suggests that steel slag effectively provides all the essential nutrients that may be limiting in control soils without treated with steel slag fertilizers. The consistent increase in rice grain weight is likely attributed to the high concentrations of plant available SiO2 provided by the steel slag. It is well known fact that Si has been involved in improving plant leaf erectness, which enhances plant efficiency of absorbing sunlight through photosynthetic activities during grain filling stage (Ning et al., 2016). While the straw yield has shown with similar increasing trend, with slight fluctuation at 4 ton ha−1 suggest a complex interaction between nutrient availability and tiller number, though the ultimate at the highest supplication of steel slag application (8 ton ha−1) has confirmed that soil capacity for increasing the biomass was not exceeded at these application rates (Das et al., 2019). It has already been proven from the previously studied literature that application of slags obtained from steel slag industries in rice filed have significantly increased the yield (Wang et al., 2015, Gwon et al., 2018; Das et al., 2020). The significant increase in rice yield was highly attributed to increase in nutrients availability including silicates and calcium in soil after treatment with steel slag application (Wang et al., 2015). As it has been proven that as the concentration of the applied steel slag was increased, the soil bearing more nutrients which alternatively can promote more robust rice straw and yield growth. Steel slag is highly rich in essential elements including CaO, MgO, Fe and Si, so increasing the application rate of steel slag also significantly increase the concentrations of these nutrients in soil (Ning et al., 2016; Wang et al., 2018), which are responsible for higher crop yield. Although Si has not been considered as an essential element for plant, however, there are numerous evidences found that justify that Si is highly beneficial for rice growth, development and resistance against abiotic stresses including metal toxicity, salt and drought stress and also against biotic stress like plant diseases and insect attacks (Liang et al., 2007; Cooke and Leishman, 2011). Several other studies have also reported that steel slags are highly rich in components like Si, Ca, Mg, and Fe which have been considered beneficial to enhance crop productivity (Lee et al., 2021). Based on such evidences, steel slags have also been highly recommended for using as fertilizers and improving soil fertility in agriculture sector (Gomez et a l., 2017; Fujisawa et al., 2012).
The sudden and sharp increase in pot water pH, irrespective of the different application levels of steel slags (reaching a peak of pH of 10 .5 at 8 ton ha−1 of the steel slag application rate) is directly attributed to the hydrolysis of CaO and MgO present in the steel slag applied which resulted into high spikes of alkalinity of the slag treated submerged soil (Minh et al., 2022). While the subsequent decline and stabilization in pH around day 42 might be attributed to the buffering capacity of rice paddy soil and neutralization of OH− ions by CO2 production by root respiration and microbial activity. The stabilization of pH between 7.5 and 8.0 is considered to be ideal for rice crop productivity, as it has enhanced significantly the availability of phosphorus and silicon while reduced the toxicity of iron in acidic soils (Wang et al., 2017).
The significant increase in C and N contents up to 4 ton ha−1 application rate indicates that steel slag amendment promotes better nutrient uptake and biomass accumulation. Which might be due to alkaline nature of steel slag, which may stimulate microbial activity, accelerating mineralization of organic matter and making N more accessible for plant uptake during early stages of plants growth (Das et al., 2019; Ning et al., 2016). However, the sudden decline in C and N concentrations observed at the highest application rate of steel slag (8 ton ha−1) was because of the dilution effect or physiological threshold. The massive and significant increase in the total biomass and grain yield at 8 ton ha−1 of the steel slag application level has more likely redistributed the plant available C and N all across the larger volume of the plant tissues, that leads to its lower concentrations despite higher total uptake. In alternative, the excessively high initial soil pH of 10.0 at 8 ton ha−1 of the steel slag applied treatment might be involved in higher ammonia (NH3) volatilization that have slightly reduced the N pool available for early season accumulation by the plants (Kim et al., 2024). For so many years, it has been great concern about using steel slag in agriculture for their huge potential to accumulate heavy metals in soil (Das et al., 2019). It was believed that long use of steel slag in agriculture sector as fertilizer could help in accumulating heavy metals in soils (Gwon et al., 2018). However, it might not be true for short term use because we did not detect any significant amount of heavy metals, neither in in the soil nor in plant samples, irrespective of the steel slag application rates.
Conclusion
Our results have clearly demonstrated that steel slag has significantly improved both rice grain and straw yield. It has also been shown that steel slag has significantly increased the soil pH, availability of plant available nutrients, SiO2, which means that steel slag can an effective and environmentally safe soil amendment for rice cropping systems. The significant increase in ripened grain weight at the 8 ton ha−1 rate, coupled with the absence of detectable heavy metal accumulation in both soil and plant tissues, suggests that steel slag can be successfully repurposed from industrial waste into a valuable agricultural resource. These findings support the adoption of steel slag to enhance rice productivity while maintaining environmental safety standards.
